Tag: #Ganguly Evera Developers LLP & Anr.

  • Garia Real Estate Project Gets Relief as Court Finds No Basis for Construction Halt

    Garia Real Estate Project Gets Relief as Court Finds No Basis for Construction Halt

    Date: 21.11.2026

    The Calcutta High Court has set aside a stop-work notice issued to the developer of the β€œ4 Sight Florence Phase III” project in Garia, holding that Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality acted without a prima facie basis and without showing that the construction was unlawful or contrary to the sanctioned plan.

    Background of the dispute

    In Ganguly Evera Developers LLP & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., decided on 17 November 2026, the developer challenged an order issued by the Executive Officer of Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality on 9 October 2026.

    The municipal action followed a complaint sent by a private individual to a local MLA. The complaint alleged a broad range of potential irregularities at the real-estate project, including issues involving road access, land records, water-body conversion, ownership, floor-area ratio (FAR), setbacks, environmental permissions, RERA compliance and alleged suppression of material facts. The MLA did not lodge an independent complaint; the communication was only forwarded to the municipality.

    Based on that forwarded representation, the municipality recorded that the developer appeared to have secured building-plan approval through β€œcoercion.” It issued a stop-work notice and directed the developer to produce original documents for verification.

    Developer’s challenge

    The petitioners argued that the municipality’s power to stop construction under Section 220 of the West Bengal Municipal Act, 1993 is limited to cases involving unauthorized or unlawful construction. They contended that the project had a sanctioned building plan and that no case of deviation from the approved plan had been made out.

    The private respondent maintained that the complaint raised serious discrepancies. However, counsel for the private respondent accepted that no complaint had been filed directly with the municipality or another statutory authority. Counsel also clarified that the private respondent’s case was not that the building plan had been obtained through coercion.

    Court’s findings

    Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury found that the municipality had granted permission for development of the project land and that there was no material before the Court showing any construction deviation or unlawful execution of the sanctioned plan.

    The Court drew a clear distinction between allegations of suppression or fraudulent procurement of approvals and a finding that an approval was obtained through coercion. While the complaint referred to alleged ownership issues and suppression of title-related facts, it contained no particulars explaining how the municipality had supposedly been coerced into granting approval.

    The Court held that the municipality’s conclusion on coercion was unsupported by documents, a formal complaint, or any stated particulars. It observed that public authorities may receive communications forwarded by elected representatives, but they must independently apply their mind before taking coercive action.

    Why the stop-work notice was invalid

    The judgment identifies three central defects in the municipal decision:

    • No evidence of unauthorized construction: The municipality did not show that the project departed from the sanctioned building plan or that the construction was unlawful.
    • No particulars of coercion: Neither the complaint nor the municipal order described any act of coercion by which approval was allegedly obtained.
    • Lack of independent scrutiny: The stop-work direction was issued on the basis of a forwarded complaint, without an independent enquiry or a prima facie evidentiary foundation.

    The Court concluded that the notice reflected non-application of mind and that, in the circumstances, the municipality should not have halted work.

    State enquiry and complaint procedure

    The State submitted that it intended to conduct an enquiry. The Court declined to grant permission for such an enquiry at the private respondent’s instance because no formal complaint had been made to the State or another statutory authority.

    At the same time, the Court clarified that the State remains free to conduct an independent or suo motu enquiry if warranted. The ruling therefore does not prevent lawful scrutiny of genuine statutory violations; it requires that such action be founded on a proper complaint, relevant material, and an informed decision by the competent authority.

    Outcome

    The High Court allowed the writ petition and quashed the stop-work notice dated 9 October 2026. The decision reinforces that municipal authorities cannot suspend a sanctioned development merely on unverified allegations forwarded through a political representative. Any stop-work action must rest on a demonstrable legal basis, supported facts, and a reasoned application of the statutory power.

    Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.

    Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.

    Handy Download: