
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration
Date: 19.11.2026
Delhi High Court Backs Contractor in WAPCOS Project Payment Dispute
This Short Article has been prepared & written by Arbitrator Shobhit Malik. The views expressed are based on his interpretation of the law. He can be reached at his mob no- +91 9712924188 and email id shobhit.Ica23@gmail.com .

The Delhi High Court has dismissed WAPCOS Limitedโs appeal and upheld an arbitral tribunalโs interim directions allowing foreclosure of the Aizawl Convention Centre project, project handover to WAPCOS, and removal of the contractorโs plant and machinery.
Background: A Nearly Completed Project Stalled by Payment Disputes
The dispute arose from the construction of a convention centre and associated infrastructure in Aizawl, Mizoram. The Ministry of Tourism appointed WAPCOS Limited as the executing agency in March 2021. WAPCOS subsequently awarded the construction contract to M.P. Khaitan for approximately Rs.30 crore in March 2022.
The original completion period was 15 months, ending on 24 June 2023. Following three extensions, the final deadline was extended to 31 August 2024. By then, M.P. Khaitan had completed about 90% of the work, although the contractor stated that only about 4% remained.
During execution, disputes developed over running-account bills, approvals for extra and deviated works, GST reimbursement, and retention money. M.P. Khaitan claimed that Rs.2.65 crore remained outstanding. In July 2024, it issued a notice seeking foreclosure of the contract, citing prolonged non-payment and the absence of financial approvals.
WAPCOS acknowledged that the contractorโs bill had been approved but said payment could not be released because funds had not been received from the Ministry of Tourism. It requested additional time and stated that it would itself issue a foreclosure recommendation if the matter could not be resolved. The payments remained unpaid, and the contractor suspended work from 27 August 2024.
The Interim Arbitral Directions
After the dispute was referred to arbitration, the sole arbitrator allowed M.P. Khaitanโs application for interim measures. The order required WAPCOS to issue a foreclosure certificate, take over the project site, and allowed the contractor to remove its plant and machinery.
The arbitrator also removed the Ministry of Tourism from the arbitration. The Ministry was not a signatory to the WAPCOSโM.P. Khaitan contract and had maintained that it was neither a necessary nor a proper party to the contractorโs claims.
WAPCOS challenged these directions under Section 37(2)(b) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
WAPCOSโs Main Arguments
WAPCOS argued that the contractโs General Conditions gave only WAPCOS the power to foreclose the contract. It contended that the contractor had no contractual right to demand foreclosure and that the arbitral tribunal had disregarded the agreed terms.
It also challenged the requirement that it take over the project. According to WAPCOS, the Special Conditions contemplated handover to the owner or client, which it identified as the Ministry of Tourism rather than WAPCOS.
Finally, WAPCOS argued that the Ministry should remain in the arbitration because it was the project owner, funding source, and ultimate recipient of the completed project.
Why the Court Refused to Interfere
The Court stressed that an appeal against an interim order under Section 17 is narrowly limited. Judicial interference is justified only where the tribunalโs decision is perverse, patently illegal, or affected by a jurisdictional error. A court cannot simply substitute its own view for a plausible view taken by an arbitral tribunal.
On foreclosure, the Court found that the tribunal had properly relied on the partiesโ correspondence. WAPCOS had admitted the outstanding payment, attributed the delay to non-release of funds by the Ministry, and indicated that it could recommend foreclosure if the situation was not resolved. These admissions supported the tribunalโs conclusion that the contractorโs request for foreclosure was justified in the circumstances.
The Court also held that although the relevant contract clause empowered WAPCOS to foreclose, it did not expressly prohibit the contractor from seeking foreclosure. Given the prolonged non-payment and the contractorโs reliance on Sections 51, 53, 54 and 55 of the Indian Contract Act, the tribunalโs approach was considered a plausible one.
Ministry of Tourism Properly Excluded from Arbitration
The Court upheld the deletion of the Ministry of Tourism from the proceedings. The central reason was the absence of contractual privity between the Ministry and M.P. Khaitan.
The Ministry had engaged WAPCOS as the executing agency and placed responsibility on it to execute, complete, manage, and deliver the project. The contractorโs agreement was with WAPCOS, not with the Ministry. The Court found no document showing that the Ministry had signed, ratified, or accepted the contractual obligations between WAPCOS and M.P. Khaitan.
The Court further observed that a clause referring to handover of the completed project to the owner or client could not, at the interim stage, impose obligations on a non-signatory Ministry. WAPCOS, as the contractorโs contractual counterparty and executing agency, could therefore be directed to take over the site.
Key Legal Takeaways
- Limited appellate review: Courts will rarely interfere with an arbitratorโs interim measures under Section 17, particularly while arbitration remains ongoing.
- Contractual silence matters: A clause granting one party a foreclosure power does not necessarily bar the other party from seeking relief where the contract does not expressly prohibit it.
- Conduct can shape interim relief: Admissions in correspondence, including acknowledgement of unpaid dues and assurances concerning foreclosure, can materially support an interim order.
- Non-signatories are not automatically necessary parties: A project funder or owner may be excluded from arbitration where it has no privity of contract with the claimant and has not accepted the relevant contractual obligations.
- Executing agencies remain accountable: Where an agency contracts directly with a contractor, it may remain responsible for project handover and related interim directions even if project funds originate from a government ministry.
The decision reinforces the principle that arbitral tribunals have broad discretion to preserve an equitable position between parties during a dispute, especially where substantial work has been completed but payments remain unresolved.
Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.
Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.
Source: Delhi High Court
Handy Download:
Write to us at office@aadrikaalaw.com
Tel: +91-11-4999 2707

