
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration
Date: 23.09.2026
Karnataka HC Refuses to Quash ED Proceedings
This Short Article has been prepared & written by Advocate G Sridharamurthy. The views expressed are based on his interpretation of the law. He can be reached at his email id sriadv3@gmail.com .

In a significant judgment concerning homebuyer complaints, delayed real-estate projects, alleged diversion of project funds and proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), the Karnataka High Court has refused to terminate criminal and money-laundering proceedings concerning the Ozone Urbana project.
Justice M. Nagaprasanna dealt together with six writ petitions filed by Ozone Urbana Infra Developers Pvt. Ltd. and its office-bearers, challenging various criminal complaints/FIRs as well as Enforcement Directorate proceedings, including ECIRs and a Provisional Attachment Order (PAO) covering properties stated to be worth βΉ423.38 crore.
The Court held, in substance, that serious allegations involving multiple homebuyers, alleged diversion and siphoning of substantial funds, non-delivery of homes and complex financial transactions could not, at the threshold, simply be reduced to private contractual disputes.
Ozone Urbana Project at Centre of Multiple Proceedings
- Ozone Urbana Infra Developers was developing a township known as βOzone Urbanaβ, comprising 12 projects with single-unit houses, low- and mid-rise units, high-rise apartments and associated infrastructure.
- According to the judgment, land for the development was acquired during 2006β2007 and construction commenced in 2012. The litigation involved the company, its Chairman and Managing Director Vasudevan Sathyamoorthy, other office-bearers, several homebuyers, police authorities and the Directorate of Enforcement.
- The connected petitions arose from different complaints and investigations but involved overlapping allegations concerning the project and its financial affairs.
Homebuyers Alleged Payment of Substantial Consideration Without Delivery of Flats
- The judgment records several complaints by individual homebuyers and the Ozone Urbana Buyers Welfare Association.
- One complaint concerned a senior-citizen homebuyer who allegedly paid βΉ64,52,418 in full for a flat in βOzone Urbana Pavilionβ. According to the complaint, even after about 10 years from the initial booking, the construction remained incomplete and possession had not been delivered.
- Another homebuyer alleged payment of βΉ1,32,10,000 towards a flat in βOzone Urbana Avenueβ. The complaint alleged that despite payment of the entire consideration, the flat was not handed over and was subsequently sold to a third person.
- These were allegations under investigation, not findings of guilt.
Buyersβ Association Alleged Project Was Only 49% Complete
- The Ozone Urbana Buyers Welfare Association also lodged a complaint.
- According to the allegations recorded in the judgment, the Ozone Urbana Township commenced in 2012 with a projected 1,800 units and was represented as being completed by 2017. The complaint alleged that only about 49% of the construction had been completed.
- The homebuyers further alleged that they had been induced through subvention schemes, tripartite arrangements and buy-back schemes. In some instances, banks and housing finance companies allegedly released up to 90% of the loan amount without adequately verifying construction progress, title or the project’s financial position.
- It was further alleged that the developer had undertaken to service pre-EMI/EMI payments until possession but subsequently stopped doing so, leaving the homebuyers to service the loans themselves.
βNeither the Home Nor the Moneyβ: Allegations Before Court
- The judgment records the complainants’ case that the affected buyers were left with βneither the home nor the moneyβ, while banks had initiated proceedings under the SARFAESI Act for non-payment of loan instalments.
- Crime No. 77 of 2024 consequently involved allegations under Sections 406, 409, 420, 120-B and 34 IPC and Section 9 of the Karnataka Protection of Interest of Depositors in Financial Establishments Act, 2004 (KPIDFE Act).
Developer: Disputes Were Civil, Contractual and Already Before RERA
- Ozone Urbana and its office-bearers argued that the controversies were fundamentally civil and contractual disputes arising from delayed construction, payment obligations and real-estate agreements.
- They contended that the essential ingredients of cheating and criminal breach of trust were absent because there was no fraudulent intention from the inception of the transactions.
- The petitioners also relied on the fact that certain homebuyers had already invoked remedies under RERA, arguing that parallel criminal proceedings based on the same underlying transaction amounted to abuse of process.
- Reliance was placed, among other authorities, on the principles governing quashing of criminal proceedings laid down in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335.
RERA Remedy Does Not Automatically Convert Criminal Allegations Into a Civil Dispute
- The broader reasoning of the judgment is important for real-estate disputes.
- The mere existence of contractual remedies, RERA proceedings or insolvency proceedings does not, by itself, require criminal allegations to be terminated where the complaint independently discloses facts capable of constituting criminal offences.
- The Court treated the allegations in the connected homebuyer matters as requiring investigation rather than a premature determination at the quashing stage.
- The judgment therefore underscores the distinction between an ordinary case of delayed possession or contractual breach and allegations extending to matters such as double sale of units, alleged diversion of funds, alleged misappropriation, subvention arrangements and other financial transactions.
2022 ECIR Also Survives Despite Technical Quashing of Predicate FIR
- A particularly significant issue concerned the 2022 ECIR β ECIR No. BGZO/70/2022.
- The ED had registered the ECIR following predicate proceedings arising from complaints concerning the Ozone Urbana project. The petitioners argued that subsequent developments affecting the predicate FIRs destroyed the foundation of the PMLA proceedings.
- The High Court rejected that contention.
- It drew a distinction between a predicate proceeding being quashed on merits, thereby striking at the substratum of the scheduled offence, and quashing based upon a technical defect, which does not necessarily erase the underlying allegations of criminality.
- The Court found that the underlying private complaint continued to subsist. It therefore held that the 2022 ECIR and the summons issued under Section 50 PMLA could not be treated as automatically foundationless merely because a predicate FIR had suffered quashing on a technical ground.
Fresh 2025 ECIR and βΉ423.38 Crore Attachment Challenged
- The company also challenged ECIR/BGZO/01/2025, registered by the ED in 2025.
- The ECIR was based on multiple predicate crimes. Meanwhile, the ED conducted search and seizure proceedings on 1 and 2 August 2025, during which digital devices and books of account were collected. Section 50 summons followed on 4 August 2025.
- A further major development arose from proceedings before the Supreme Court concerning homebuyers, builders, banks and housing finance companies operating under subvention schemes.
- The Supreme Court proceedings eventually led to a CBI investigation and registration of an FIR alleging offences under Section 420 read with Section 120-B IPC and Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
- That CBI FIR was subsequently added to the 2025 ECIR.
ED Provisionally Attached Properties Worth βΉ423.38 Crore
- On 4 October 2025, the Directorate of Enforcement issued a Provisional Attachment Order under Section 5(1) PMLA.
- According to the ED’s press release reproduced in the judgment, immovable properties valued at βΉ423.38 crore were provisionally attached.
- The attached assets were stated to include unsold inventory comprising 92 flats in the Avenue project and 13 flats in Aqua 2, approximately 4.5 acres of commercial land, and personal properties of the promoter and his wife, including land at Kannehalli Village, Mudigere.
- The ED alleged that the company and its promoter had generated proceeds of crime of approximately βΉ927.22 crore through alleged diversion of funds. Importantly, these figures represent the ED’s allegations recorded in the proceedings, not a final judicial determination of money laundering or the quantum of proceeds of crime.
Karnataka HC Refuses to Quash 2025 ECIR
- The High Court rejected the argument that the 2025 ECIR lacked a surviving predicate offence.
- It observed that the predicate proceedings remained alive and that one of the underlying crimes arose from a CBI investigation pursuant to directions of the Supreme Court.
- The allegations had yet to undergo investigation and trial. At this stage, the High Court said it could not presume that those proceedings had ceased to exist and, on that assumption, terminate consequential PMLA proceedings.
- The Court accordingly held that so long as the scheduled offence subsists and the proceedings concerning it have not been obliterated, the ECIR cannot be treated as foundationless.
Provisional Attachment Is Not Final Determination of βProceeds of Crimeβ
- The Court also refused to interfere with the PAO at this stage.
- An important qualification in the judgment is that a provisional attachment is not a final judicial determination that the property constitutes proceeds of crime.
- Questions concerning the nexus between alleged criminal activity and the attached property, whether the assets satisfy the statutory definition of βproceeds of crimeβ, and whether the attachment can ultimately be sustained are matters for the adjudicatory mechanism prescribed under the PMLA.
- The Court therefore rejected the attempt to have those questions conclusively determined in the writ proceedings at the provisional-attachment stage.
PMLA Provides Complete Statutory Mechanism Against Attachment
- The High Court relied upon the Supreme Court’s decision in JSW Steel Ltd. v. Enforcement Directorate, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2150.
- It emphasised the statutory structure under which Section 5 permits provisional attachment, Section 8 provides adjudication and confirmation before the Adjudicating Authority, and Section 26 provides an appellate remedy before the Appellate Tribunal.
- The High Court held that interfering with a provisional attachment at its threshold would effectively short-circuit the adjudicatory mechanism established by Parliament.
Economic Offence Allegations Cannot Be Viewed Through Narrow Contractual Lens: HC
- One of the strongest parts of the judgment concerns the Court’s treatment of the alleged economic offences.
- The High Court observed that the allegations were not confined to a single complainant or an isolated contractual transaction. They involved allegations of financial transactions of considerable magnitude, diversion and siphoning of funds and use of money for purposes different from those for which it had allegedly been collected.
- The Court noted that such allegations affected numerous stakeholders, particularly homebuyers.
- It observed that for a homebuyer, purchase of a home is often not merely an investment in property but the culmination of years of savings coupled with the continuing burden of a housing loan.
- The allegations therefore could not, at this stage, be examined merely through the narrow prism of individual contractual disputes.
Court Calls for βFull and Unhindered Investigationβ
- Considering the alleged movement and diversion of substantial funds and the number of affected persons, the Court held that the matter had wider economic and societal ramifications.
- It found that such allegations warranted a full and unhindered investigation in accordance with law.
- At a stage when the allegations remained to be tested through the legally prescribed process, interdiction of the proceedings was held to be inappropriate.
Civil and Criminal Remedies Can Operate in Their Own Fields
- The judgment is particularly relevant to developers and homebuyers because it demonstrates that resort to RERA, civil proceedings or insolvency remedies does not necessarily create immunity against criminal investigation.
- The crucial inquiry remains whether the allegations, taken at face value, disclose ingredients of an independent criminal offence.
- Thus, an ordinary contractual delay may stand on one footing; allegations involving dishonest inducement, double sale, diversion of money, breach of trust, conspiracy or laundering of alleged proceeds of crime may stand on another.
- The existence of a civil remedy is therefore not, by itself, decisive of whether criminal proceedings should be quashed.
Court Also Examines KPIDFE Act in Context of Homebuyer Funds
- Another important question concerned the applicability of the Karnataka Protection of Interest of Depositors in Financial Establishments Act.
- The petitioners argued that developers were not financial establishments and that purchasers of flats could not simultaneously be treated as βdepositorsβ.
- The judgment examined authorities dealing with similarly worded depositor-protection legislation, including decisions addressing the breadth of the expressions βdepositβ and βfinancial establishmentβ and their potential application to money collected by builders from flat purchasers.
- This aspect assumes particular importance where funds are collected from the public against a promise to provide property or another specified service and the transaction is alleged to have resulted in fraudulent default.
Key Principle on PMLA Predicate Offences
- Another significant legal principle emerging from the ruling is that quashing of a predicate FIR does not invariably and mechanically result in termination of an ECIR.
- The reason for quashing the predicate proceeding matters.
- Where the scheduled offence itself is extinguished on merits, the consequences under PMLA may be materially different. But where a particular FIR is quashed because of a procedural or technical defect while the underlying complaint and allegations remain alive, the Court held that PMLA proceedings cannot necessarily be treated as having lost their foundation.
- That distinction could have wider implications for future PMLA litigation.
Ozone Urbanaβs Challenge to ED Proceedings Fails
- Ultimately, the High Court declined to halt the ED’s investigation and refused to interfere with the provisional attachment at this stage.
- The ruling does not amount to a finding that Ozone Urbana, its promoters or office-bearers are guilty of cheating, diversion of funds or money laundering. Those allegations remain subject to investigation, statutory adjudication and, where applicable, trial.
- What the Court decided at this stage was that the allegations and surviving predicate proceedings provided sufficient legal basis for the investigations and statutory processes to continue, and that the High Court’s extraordinary jurisdiction could not be used to terminate them prematurely.
Why the Judgment Matters
The 210-page ruling is important at the intersection of RERA, criminal law, PMLA, depositor-protection legislation and insolvency law.
For homebuyers, it reinforces that pursuing remedies under RERA or other civil/statutory forums does not necessarily prevent them from invoking criminal law where the factual allegations independently disclose criminality.
For developers and promoters, the judgment illustrates that the defence of a βpurely civil disputeβ will not automatically succeed at the quashing stage where allegations extend beyond mere delay in construction or contractual non-performance to alleged dishonest inducement, multiple sales, diversion of funds or other financial wrongdoing.
For PMLA proceedings, the ruling reiterates that a provisional attachment under Section 5 is only an interim statutory measure and that disputes regarding whether the attached assets actually constitute βproceeds of crimeβ ordinarily have to travel through the statutory adjudication and appellate process.
Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.
Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.
Source: Karnataka High Court
Handy Download:
Write to us at office@aadrikaalaw.com
Tel: +91-11-4999 2707


Leave a Reply