
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration
Date: 21.11.2026
Karnataka High Court Quashes Section 338 IPC Proceedings in Alleged Eye-Treatment Negligence
This Short Article has been prepared & written by Advocate G Sridharamurthy. The views expressed are based on his interpretation of the law. He can be reached at his mob no- +91 9845906418 and email id sriadv3@gmail.com .

The Karnataka High Court quashed criminal proceedings arising from allegations of negligent eye treatment because the complaint and investigation did not satisfy the mandatory safeguard of obtaining credible, independent medical opinion before proceeding against medical professionals.
Background of the case
A patient filed a private criminal complaint alleging that an eye-care institution and its medical practitioners had been negligent in performing implantable contact lens procedures and in providing subsequent care. The complaint alleged inadequate pre-operative assessment, failure to explain material risks, delayed response to recurring symptoms, and insufficient management of increased intraocular pressure.
According to the allegations, the patient underwent further procedures after experiencing worsening vision and was later assessed by other medical institutions. The patient claimed to have suffered permanent visual disability and attributed the outcome to negligent treatment. A complaint was also made before the relevant medical regulatory body, followed by a private complaint seeking investigation for an offence under Section 338 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
The Magistrate directed the police to investigate, following which an FIR was registered. The accused medical institution and practitioners challenged the order and the FIR before the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Central legal issue: safeguards in criminal allegations against doctors
The Court considered whether criminal proceedings for alleged medical negligence could continue when the complaint was not supported by an independent expert medical opinion.
The Court reaffirmed the safeguards established by the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, Martin F. D’Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq, and A.S.V. Narayan Rao v. Ratnamala. These decisions recognise that medical professionals should not be exposed to routine criminal prosecution merely because treatment resulted in an adverse outcome.
For a criminal case of medical negligence to proceed, two protections are important:
- Prima facie expert support: A complainant must ordinarily produce a credible opinion from a competent medical professional indicating rashness or negligence.
- Independent opinion during investigation: Investigating authorities must obtain an independent medical opinion, preferably from a government doctor, before proceeding against a medical professional.
The Court emphasised that criminal negligence requires a substantially higher threshold than civil negligence. The conduct alleged must indicate gross negligence or negligence of a very high degree, rather than an ordinary error of judgment or an unsuccessful clinical outcome.
Why the proceedings were quashed
The private complaint asserted that another ophthalmologist had linked the loss of vision to the earlier treatment. However, no written report or independent expert opinion supporting that assertion was attached to the complaint.
The Court found that:
- the complaint was not accompanied by the required independent, competent medical opinion;
- the police registered the FIR without first obtaining an independent opinion from a government medical expert; and
- a Magistrateβs direction to investigate does not remove the requirement to follow these safeguards.
The Court distinguished a cited decision in which criminal proceedings were permitted to continue because the police had already considered expert medical opinion at the FIR stage. In the present matter, that foundational expert material was absent.
Delay and medical-regulatory proceedings
The medical professionals also argued that the complaint had been filed after a significant delay and after a complaint before the medical regulatory authority had failed. The Court held that delay alone does not justify quashing an FIR unless it is unexplained and demonstrably deliberate.
Here, the treatment history and events leading to the complaint were described in detail, and the complaint was within the statutory limitation period applicable to the alleged offence.
The Court also noted that the medical regulatory authority had dismissed the complaint after conducting an inquiry. Although that finding formed part of the background, the High Courtβs decision principally rested on non-compliance with the mandatory procedural protections for medical professionals facing criminal-negligence allegations.
Decision and legal significance
The High Court allowed the petition and quashed:
- the Magistrateβs order directing investigation;
- the private criminal complaint; and
- the FIR registered for the alleged offence under Section 338 of the Indian Penal Code.
The ruling reinforces that criminal medical-negligence complaints must begin with credible independent medical support. Courts and investigating authorities cannot treat allegations of an adverse medical outcome as sufficient, by themselves, to initiate criminal action against healthcare providers.
The decision preserves a patientβs ability to pursue supported claims while protecting medical professionals from criminal proceedings initiated without the expert foundation required by law.
Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.
Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.
Source: Karnataka High Court
Handy Download:
Write to us at office@aadrikaalaw.com
Tel: +91-11-4999 2707


Leave a Reply