Bombay High Court Clarifies When Development Agreements Must Be Registered Under RERA

Date: 16.11.2026

In Edcon Real Estate Developers v. Goa Real Estate Regulatory Authority, the High Court upheld the decisions of the Goa RERA Authority and the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. The Court found that the development agreement relied upon by the developer created identifiable rights in immovable property and therefore had to be registered under Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908.

The ruling clarifies that not every development agreement must automatically be registered. Whether registration is mandatory depends on the document’s actual legal effect, rather than its title or label.

Background of the dispute

Edcon Real Estate Developers entered into a development agreement dated 1 February 2020 with the owners of land measuring about 3,050 square metres at Calangute, Goa. Under the arrangement, the developer was to obtain approvals, construct the project, and receive a share of the completed development instead of monetary consideration.

The agreement apportioned the proposed super built-up area as follows:

  • 50% to the developer;
  • 40% to the landowners; and
  • 10%, along with specified development-expense reimbursement, to a confirming party.

The developer applied to Goa RERA to register the project. RERA required the developer to produce a registered development agreement, taking the view that the agreement created rights in immovable property. The developer challenged that requirement, arguing that the document was only an executory commercial arrangement and did not transfer ownership or possession of the land.

Developer’s argument: only a licence and future contractual rights

The developer relied heavily on a clause stating that possession of the land would remain with the owners throughout the agreement. It said the developer had only an irrevocable licence to enter the property and undertake construction.

According to the developer, the agreement did not itself transfer any title, right, or interest in the land. It merely set out obligations for future development and contemplated future conveyance deeds after completion of construction. The developer also argued that Rule 3 of the Goa RERA Rules requires production of a development or collaboration agreement but does not expressly require every such agreement to be registered.

RERA’s position: the agreement was the legal basis for development rights

Goa RERA maintained that project registration is not a purely administrative exercise. Where an applicant is not the landowner, the authority must verify that the applicant has legally enforceable authority to develop, market, sell, and complete the project as a promoter.

RERA pointed to provisions giving the developer a defined 50% share in the completed project, the exclusive right to retain or sell that share, and the power to nominate purchasers for whom the landowners would execute conveyances. In RERA’s view, these provisions created substantial rights connected with the project and the corresponding undivided interest in the land.

High Court’s ruling: limited scrutiny is within RERA’s jurisdiction

The Court held that Goa RERA does not become a registering authority or a civil court merely because it examines a development agreement. It cannot finally decide title disputes or broadly rule on a document’s validity under the Registration Act.

However, it can conduct a limited, incidental examination of the agreement when deciding a project-registration application. This is because the agreement is the foundation of a non-owner developer’s authority to act as a promoter.

The Court reasoned that treating production of the agreement as a mere formality would undermine the purpose of RERA. The authority cannot be required to accept any document simply because it is called a β€œDevelopment Agreement.”

Why this agreement required registration

The Court read the agreement as a whole, particularly its provisions on the allocation and disposal of the completed project. It found that the agreement did more than grant a licence to build.

Key features included:

  • the developer’s defined entitlement to 50% of the completed built-up area;
  • the developer’s authority to retain or independently sell its allocated units;
  • the corresponding proportionate undivided interest in the underlying land; and
  • the landowners’ binding obligation to execute conveyances in favour of purchasers nominated by the developer.

Although legal title to the land would pass through later conveyances, the Court held that the agreement had already fixed the parties’ beneficial and commercial rights in the completed project. Those rights went beyond a simple promise to execute a future conveyance.

The Court therefore concluded that the agreement created or declared rights in immovable property within the meaning of Section 17 of the Registration Act and required compulsory registration.

Important legal principles from the decision

The judgment establishes several important principles for developers, landowners, and RERA authorities:

  • Labels are not decisive. Calling a document a development agreement, collaboration agreement, or licence agreement does not determine whether registration is required.
  • Each agreement must be assessed on its own terms. The Court rejected both extremes: not every development agreement is automatically registrable, but neither is every such agreement merely contractual.
  • Future conveyances do not necessarily prevent present registrable rights. A later conveyance may be needed to perfect legal title, while the development agreement can still create present beneficial or proprietary incidents.
  • Possession is relevant but not conclusive. Retention of possession by the landowner does not settle the registration issue if the agreement otherwise creates rights in the project or land.
  • RERA’s scrutiny is limited. RERA may assess the legal efficacy of the foundational agreement for project registration, but it cannot conduct a full title adjudication.
  • Section 13 of RERA was not applicable. That provision concerns agreements for sale between promoters and allottees; the dispute instead concerned the developer’s authority under Sections 3 and 4 of RERA and Rule 3 of the Goa Rules.

Impact on Goa real estate projects

The decision reinforces the importance of reviewing development agreements before filing a RERA registration application. Where the agreement allocates a defined project share to a developer, authorises sales, connects that share with an undivided land interest, and obliges owners to execute conveyances for the developer’s nominees, registration may be mandatory.

For RERA purposes, an unregistered agreement that legally requires registration may not provide an adequate foundation for a developer to seek recognition as the project’s promoter. The decision also supports greater transparency for buyers by requiring the developer’s authority and obligations to rest on legally effective documentation.

Outcome

The High Court dismissed Edcon Real Estate Developers’ second appeal and upheld the orders of Goa RERA and the appellate tribunal. It declared that the development agreement required registration under Section 17 of the Registration Act.

The developer was permitted to present the agreement for registration and, after registering it, pursue its project-registration application before Goa RERA. The authority must then assess the application on its merits under RERA and the Goa Rules.

Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.

Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.

Handy Download:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Discover more from π€πšππ«π’π€πšπš π‹πžπ πšπ₯ π’πžπ«π―π’πœπžπ¬ (𝐀𝐋𝐒)

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading