Pre-2019 Solar EPC Contracts: Supreme Court Strikes Down Retrospective GST Demand

Date: 17.11.2026

The Supreme Court has ruled that the 70:30 GST valuation mechanism for solar EPC contracts cannot be imposed retrospectively on supplies made before 1 January 2019, and that a detachable solar power generating (SPG) system is not automatically a works contract merely because it is mounted on a civil foundation.

The dispute: GST demand on solar EPC projects

Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd., an EPC contractor that supplies and installs solar power generating systems across India, faced a GST demand for projects executed between 1 July 2017 and 31 December 2018. The tax authorities treated these turnkey contracts as works contracts and applied a valuation split of 70% goods and 30% services.

This approach resulted in 5% GST on 70% of the contract value and 18% GST on the remaining 30%. The demand, including CGST, SGST and penalties, totalled approximately β‚Ή53.36 crore.

The company had instead paid GST at 5% on the supply and installation of the SPG systems, relying on the then-applicable entry for solar power generating systems under the GST rate notification.

How the GST regime changed from 2019

When GST was introduced, renewable energy devices, including a solar power generating system, were covered by a concessional 5% GST rate. The policy reflected the GST Council’s objective of limiting the cost impact on renewable-energy generation.

From 1 January 2019, the Government introduced a specific valuation mechanism for renewable-energy EPC contracts. Under this mechanism:

  • 70% of gross consideration is deemed to be the value of eligible goods and taxed at 5%.
  • 30% is deemed to be the value of specified services and taxed at 18%.
  • The effective combined GST rate becomes 8.9%.

For example, on a contract value of β‚Ή10,000, the pre-2019 5% rate produced GST of β‚Ή500. Under the later 70:30 method, GST would be β‚Ή350 on the goods portion plus β‚Ή540 on the services portion, or β‚Ή890 in total.

The Court’s key finding: the 70:30 formula was optional for the earlier period

In 2021, the Government issued a circular allowing taxpayers to use the 70:30 method for eligible renewable-energy projects completed between 1 July 2017 and 31 December 2018. The tax department treated that clarification as compulsory and issued demands accordingly.

The Supreme Court rejected that interpretation. It held that the language of the circular, stating that GST β€œcan” be paid using the 70:30 ratio for the earlier period, gave taxpayers an option. It did not require every taxpayer to retrospectively revalue pre-2019 supplies using that formula.

The Court emphasized that the 2018 notifications creating the 70:30 scheme expressly took effect from 1 January 2019. They did not operate retrospectively. Accordingly, the department could not mandate the later regime for transactions completed under the earlier legal framework.

Solar EPC supply was not a works contract on these facts

The Revenue also argued that the turnkey supply and installation arrangement was a works contract because the SPG systems were installed on civil foundations and therefore became immovable property.

The Court disagreed. It distinguished between a composite supply and a works contract:

  • A composite supply may include goods and services supplied together.
  • A works contract is a narrower category that requires work relating to an immovable property end product.

The Court found that the solar panels and related SPG components could be detached from their foundations and used elsewhere. Their attachment was intended to provide stability and enable efficient operation, not to create a permanent addition to the land or to improve the beneficial enjoyment of the foundation.

Applying established tests on annexation, intention, functionality, permanency and marketability, the Court held that such SPG systems remained movable property. The presence of limited civil work in the EPC contract did not, by itself, convert the transaction into a works contract.

Extended limitation and penalty could not stand

The department had alleged wilful misstatement and suppression of facts, invoking the extended limitation period and imposing penalties. The Court found this unsustainable.

Because the 70:30 valuation model came into force only on 1 January 2019, the taxpayer could not be accused of suppressing facts or misrepresenting its tax position by not applying that later method to earlier transactions. The Court reiterated that allegations of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression require clear foundational facts; merely using those labels is insufficient.

Outcome and business significance

The Supreme Court set aside the tax order dated 17 January 2025 and the consequential summary order dated 24 January 2025. Each party was directed to bear its own costs.

The ruling provides important clarity for renewable-energy EPC contracts executed before 1 January 2019:

  • The 70:30 goods-services valuation formula cannot be compulsorily applied to that earlier period.
  • A 2021 clarification gave taxpayers an option to adopt the formula; it did not impose a retroactive obligation.
  • Installation on a foundation does not alone make a solar generating system immovable property.
  • A solar EPC arrangement is not necessarily a works contract simply because it includes installation and civil-work elements.
  • Tax demands based on a retrospective application of the 70:30 method, including related extended-limitation allegations and penalties, lack legal support on these facts.

The judgment reinforces a broader GST principle: tax classification and valuation must follow the legal regime applicable when the supply occurred, rather than a later framework retroactively imposed by the authorities.

Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.

Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.

Handy Download:


Discover more from π€πšππ«π’π€πšπš π‹πžπ πšπ₯ π’πžπ«π―π’πœπžπ¬ (𝐀𝐋𝐒)

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Discover more from π€πšππ«π’π€πšπš π‹πžπ πšπ₯ π’πžπ«π―π’πœπžπ¬ (𝐀𝐋𝐒)

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading