
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration
Date: 20.11.2026
Delhi HC Applies Forum Conveniens to Patent, Trademark, Copyright and Design Disputes

This Short Article has been prepared & written by Advocate Ravi Shekhar Jha-Delhi High Court, New Delhi. The views expressed are based on his interpretation of the law. He can be reached at his email id intelconsul@gmail.com .
The Delhi High Court has returned ten intellectual-property suits to be filed before more appropriate courts, holding that a thin connection with Delhi cannot be used to justify forum shopping.
In a consolidated judgment, Justice examined ten commercial intellectual-property disputes involving patents, trademarks, copyrights, designs, passing off, trade secrets and content-licensing claims. The Court held that territorial jurisdiction is not simply a technical gateway: even where a small part of a cause of action may arise in Delhi, the Court can decline to hear the matter if another forum has a substantially closer and more meaningful connection to the dispute.
The decision applies the doctrine of forum conveniens, which asks which court is the most suitable forum to adjudicate a case based on the location of the parties, the alleged infringement, the underlying commercial activity, relevant documents, transactions and contractual arrangements.
The central principle: identify where the dispute truly originates
The Court stressed that IP disputes often involve several acts, such as manufacturing, advertising, offering goods for sale, online listings, sales, distribution and exports. The fact that one of those acts has a link to Delhi does not automatically make Delhi the proper place for a suit seeking relief against the entire alleged infringement.
Instead, courts must identify the material, integral and essential part of the cause of action. In practical terms, this means determining where the alleged wrongdoing principally occurred and where the dispute has its real commercial and factual centre of gravity.
The judgment warns that allowing every online listing, isolated delivery or sample purchase to create jurisdiction could make hundreds of courts equally available for the same dispute. That result, the Court held, would undermine predictability, fairness and the territorial limits of courts.
Online access alone does not establish jurisdiction
A recurring issue across the suits was reliance on websites, e-commerce platforms and online marketplaces that could be accessed in Delhi. The Court reaffirmed that mere accessibility of a website or product listing does not show that a defendant carries on business in Delhi.
For online activity to support jurisdiction, the claimant must generally show that the defendant purposefully targeted customers in the forum and that commercially concluded transactions occurred there. A website being visible nationwide, without more, cannot give every court in India jurisdiction.
The Court also cautioned against using investigator-led or βtrapβ purchases to manufacture jurisdiction. Such transactions may be considered only in limited circumstances, including where they fairly evidence genuine sales already occurring in the forum. A sole purchase arranged by a plaintiff or its agent, particularly where the pleadings and supporting documents are deficient, will ordinarily not be enough.
Jurisdiction must be proved separately for each remedy
The ruling distinguishes between different IP causes of action. A claim for patent infringement is governed by the Code of Civil Procedure, while trademark and copyright laws provide certain specialised jurisdictional provisions. Where a plaintiff combines claims, such as patent infringement and copyright infringement, jurisdiction must be independently established for each relief.
The Court rejected the proposition that a copyright-based jurisdictional provision can automatically support a patent claim merely because both are included in one suit. Similarly, the presence of a plaintiffβs branch office in Delhi is insufficient where the law requires both a relevant office and a cause of action arising at that location.
How the principle was applied across the cases
In Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. and Others, a Spanish company alleged infringement of its patent and copyright relating to smart underground waste bins. The dispute centred on a tender issued by the Gandhinagar Municipal Corporation for work in Gandhinagar, Gujarat. Although one defendant had a Delhi connection and the plaintiff said its Indian operations were centred in Delhi, the Court found that the tender, the alleged infringement and the project were all materially connected to Gujarat. The plaint was returned.
In Gebr. Schmid GmbH v. Waaree Energies Ltd., the plaintiff alleged patent infringement involving technology used in processing solar cells and related substrates. The defendantβs alleged manufacturing activity occurred in Gujarat. Delhi-based website access, an alleged offer for sale and delivery of samples did not outweigh Gujaratβs direct connection with the manufacture and core alleged infringement.
In HLE Glascoat Limited v. Sachin Industries Limited and Mold-Tek Packaging Limited v. Ideal Technoplast Industries Limited, the Court found that the disputes were fundamentally rooted in Gujarat, where the parties and alleged manufacturing activities were located. Online promotion and availability in Delhi did not justify moving the disputes to Delhi.
In Novartis AG v. Lucius Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd. and Others, the Court considered allegations involving an infringing version of the patented cancer drug Dabrafenib. While the plaintiffs relied on alleged sales and deliveries in Delhi, the Court held that Mumbai had a stronger connection because the Indian operating company, marketing and import licence were located there.
In Global Music Junction Pvt. Ltd. v. Songbird Digital India Pvt. Ltd. and Others, the dispute arose from music-content licensing agreements. The agreements were between parties based principally in Mumbai and Patna and contained jurisdiction clauses favouring Mumbai. The Court held that the availability of content to viewers in Delhi, or alleged business impact felt there, did not create a meaningful Delhi cause of action.
The Court reached similar conclusions in the remaining matters involving confectionery-jar design rights, pharmaceutical trademarks, a proposed prenatal supplement product, and alleged trade-secret and engine-related IP misuse.
Forum conveniens limits forum shopping
The Courtβs reasoning makes clear that the existence of some jurisdiction does not compel a court to entertain a suit. The doctrine of forum conveniens requires a court to balance the partiesβ interests, the convenience of litigation and the public interest in having a dispute decided where it is most closely connected.
The judgment draws support from earlier judicial authority cautioning that parties should not choose a court merely because it is perceived as better suited to IP litigation. Where the parties, business activity and factual origin of a dispute are concentrated in another location, the courts of that location will ordinarily be better placed to decide the matter.
Outcome
The Court returned the plaints in all ten commercial suits under Order VII Rule 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiffs may present their cases before courts with appropriate territorial jurisdiction.
The ruling is a significant reminder for IP owners and litigants: a well-founded infringement claim still must be filed in the forum with the most substantial connection to the alleged wrongdoing. Website accessibility, a minor sale, or an isolated delivery in Delhi will not, by itself, displace the natural forum where the disputeβs core events occurred.
Aadrikaa Legal Services is a trusted legal and regulatory support partner providing end-to-end legal solutions to law firms, corporate organizations, and businesses across India. We specialize in paralegal services, litigation support, tax and regulatory matters, delivering reliable, efficient, and result-oriented legal assistance.
Our services include comprehensive paralegal support, drafting and documentation, legal research, case management, litigation handling, and representation support across various judicial and quasi-judicial forums. We also assist in direct and indirect tax matters, customs, GST, corporate regulatory compliance, and legal advisory.
Source: Delhi High Court
Handy Download:
Write to us at office@aadrikaalaw.com
Tel: +91-11-4999 2707
Ravi Shekhar Jha – Advocate, Bar Council of Delhi


Leave a Reply